I’ll be straight with you. I once left a first-print copy of Betrayal at Baldur’s Gate on a basement shelf for one summer. One summer. When I came back, the box looked like a sad, wavy potato chip. The tiles had started separating into layers. My friend just looked at me and said “you killed it.”
He was right. I killed it.
And that’s why you’re reading this, right? You’ve got something in your collection that makes your heart race a little when you pick it up. Maybe it’s a Kickstarter all-in pledge you waited two years for. Maybe it’s your dad’s copy of Axis & Allies from 1984. Maybe you just spent $400 on a sealed Fireball Island and you’re terrified to even breathe near it.
I get it. Let’s talk about what actually works. Not the perfect museum-curator advice. The real stuff.
The First Thing Nobody Tells You
You know what’s killed more rare board games than anything else? Not spills. Not angry ex-roommates.
Your own storage spot
Think about where your games live right now. Be honest.
- That closet on the outside wall of your apartment? Yeah, that wall sweats in winter.
- The top of your bookshelf by the window? Sun is bleaching that box art two shades lighter every month.
- Under your bed? Unless you vacuum under there regularly (you don’t), dust and moisture are having a party on your cardboard.
We learned this the hard way running our storage unit service. People come to us after the damage is already done. They open a box and that musty smell hits them. Their face falls. And I always feel bad because I know they could have fixed it six months earlier for basically no money.
So here’s the real first step: admit where you’re keeping these games right now is probably wrong. I’m not judging. My games lived in a garage for two years. I still have nightmares about it.
The Cheap Fixes That Actually Work
Don’t let people tell you you need to spend $200 on special boxes. That’s nonsense. Here’s what I actually use.
- Silica gel packets: The ones that come in shoe boxes. Save them. Or buy a 50-pack on Amazon for eight bucks. Throw one inside every rare game. Replace every few months. That’s it. That alone stops humidity from curling your boards.
- Gallon-sized freezer bags: Not Ziploc brand necessarily, any thick one. Put the whole game inside. Squeeze the air out. Seal it. Then put the game back in its box. The bag takes the moisture hit before your components do. Ugly? Yes. Does it work? Absolutely.
- Card sleeves for everything: Even the cards you don’t think matter. Your fingers are greasy. I don’t care how clean you think your hands are. I’ve seen a $50 promo card get ruined because someone ate pizza and then shuffled. Just sleeve them. Use clear ones so you can still read everything.
The Stacking Mistake Almost Everyone Makes
Here’s something I learned after crushing the corner of my Scythe legendary box.
Don’t stack games like books on their side. You know, like how you see in fancy Instagram photos? That’s for looks, not for safety. When a game sits vertically, all the little bits inside slowly slide down. Cards slip out of their grooves. Miniatures snap. Rulebooks get a permanent bend.
Stack them flat. But here’s the catch – don’t stack more than four. I don’t care how sturdy they look. Gravity is patient. Stack five or six and the bottom box will start to bow in the middle. You won’t notice for months. Then one day you open it and the board doesn’t lie flat anymore.
Also – and this sounds obvious but you’d be surprised – put the heavy games on the bottom. Your light party games on top. I once put Twilight Imperium (that box is like a cinder block) on top of Codenames. Crushed it like a soda can.
When to Just Get a Storage Unit
Look, I know everyone says “just keep your games in your living room.” But some of us don’t have that option. Maybe you have roommates. Maybe your apartment is 700 square feet and your collection outgrew it two Kickstarters ago. Maybe you live in Florida or Texas or anywhere that humidity is basically a personality trait.
We see this all the time at Nearby Storage Rentals. Someone comes in with three bins full of board games and says “I finally admitted I can’t keep these in my garage anymore.” And we help them get a small, climate-controlled unit. Nothing fancy. Just dry, stable, and locked.
Here’s the thing – a good storage unit keeps your games at the same temperature year round. No summer attic heat. No winter garage cold. No basement dampness. The games just… sit there. Not aging. Not warping. Not dying.
If you’ve got more than ten rare games? Seriously consider it. It costs less than replacing one ruined Kickstarter exclusive.
What to Do If You Already Messed Up
Okay, so maybe you’re reading this because you already damaged something. I’ve been there. Here’s what actually helps.
- Warped board: Put it under your mattress for a week. Not kidding. The weight and slight warmth flattens most cardboard back out. Works better than books because the pressure is even.
- Dented box corner: You can’t fully fix this. But you can hide it. Get some corner protectors – those little metal or plastic brackets. Snap them on. Now it looks intentional instead of sad.
- Water stain: This one hurts. Blot it immediately with a dry towel. Don’t rub – you’ll smear the ink. Then point a fan at it for 24 hours. You won’t remove the stain but you’ll stop the swelling.
- Mold: This is the one that scares me. If you see fuzzy spots, isolate that game now. Put it in a trash bag by itself. Wipe the spots with rubbing alcohol on a Q-tip – not soaked, just damp. Then let it sit in direct sunlight for an hour. Sun kills mold. If the mold is inside the cardboard though? I’m sorry. That game is gone. Throw it out before it spreads to others.
One Last Thing From Someone Who’s Ruined Games
I’ve destroyed a Heroscape master set. I’ve melted the shrink wrap on a rare Glory to Rome by leaving it in a hot car. I once lost half the pieces to Magic Realm because I stored it loose in a tote.
I’m not telling you this to make you feel bad for me. I’m telling you so you know I’m not some perfect collector lecturing from a tower. I’m just a guy who learned the hard way.
Your games are meant to be played. But they’re also meant to last. You don’t have to go crazy with expensive preservation gear. Just pay attention to humidity, stacking, and where you put them.
And if you don’t have a good spot in your home? That’s fine. That’s what we’re here for. Our storage unit service has spaces that are perfect for this – small, dry, climate-controlled, and way cheaper than replacing a single rare out-of-print game.
Go check your shelf right now. Pick one box. Open it. Smell it. If it smells like basement, you’ve got work to do. But don’t stress. You caught it in time.
Most people don’t. You just did.
0 Comments